top of page

Interest Rates: Should Australian Farmers Fix or Stay Variable?

Nov 3
5 min read
Australian farmer considering fixed and variable farm loan interest rates while reviewing cash flow and financial information.

Why managing interest rate risk is about protecting your farm's financial position, not predicting what the Reserve Bank will do next.


With the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) cash rate at 4.85% and inflation remaining stubborn, it's understandable that Australian farmers are again questioning whether to fix their interest rates.

The question has come up several times recently in discussions with clients.

"Should I fix my interest rate before it goes up again?"

My response is almost always the same.

"Why?"

The usual answer is, "Because if interest rates go up, I'll have to pay more interest."

Well, yes. That's how variable interest rates work.

But that doesn't necessarily make fixing the right decision.

Having spent much of my career trading interest rates in financial markets, followed by years in agricultural banking and now advising farming families, I've seen this question from several perspectives.

And one thing hasn't changed.

Making a decision based on where you think interest rates are heading is not the same as managing interest rate risk.


Before You Fix, Answer These Five Questions

Before changing your farm loan from a variable to a fixed interest rate, I'd suggest working through five questions.

1. How much debt do you have?

What would an interest rate increase of 0.25%, 0.50% or even 1.00% actually cost your farm business in dollars?

2. What difference would that make to your budget and cash flow?

Would those additional interest costs materially affect your financial position, planned expenditure or the goals you've set for this season and next?

3. How much will fixing cost?

What's the difference between your current variable interest rate and the fixed rate your bank is offering? What does that difference represent in actual dollars over the proposed fixed-rate period?

4. What flexibility might you lose?

Would fixing restrict your ability to repay debt, restructure borrowing or take advantage of lower interest rates?

5. What are you actually trying to protect?

Are you fixing because you're concerned interest rates might rise, or because you've identified a financial outcome that needs protecting?

The answers should determine your decision, not predictions about the next RBA announcement.


Why Rising Interest Rates Concern Farmers

I'm not insensitive to the anxiety that rising interest rates can create.

Those of my generation who were borrowing through the late 1980s will remember interest rates of 18% or more, particularly during 1989.

For many farming families, those were difficult years. High interest costs, declining financial flexibility and the pressure of meeting repayments created genuine financial stress.

I remember that period, and I understand why even the suggestion of rising rates can make borrowers uncomfortable.

But interest rates need to be considered in the context of today's debt levels, farm income, operating costs and financial circumstances.

The question isn't simply whether interest rates might rise.

It's whether your farm business can manage the consequences if they do.

And if it can't, what action makes the most financial sense?


Are Future Interest Rate Increases Already Priced In?

One of the things I learned early in financial markets is that interest rates don't wait for the RBA to make an announcement.

Money markets are constantly trading on expectations about inflation, economic conditions and what central banks might do next.

By the time the RBA announces a rate increase, wholesale financial markets may have been pricing that possibility for weeks or months.

If your farm loan has a variable rate linked to market interest rates, some of that anticipated increase may already be reflected in what you're paying. The extent depends on how your loan is priced and when its rate resets.

And the fixed rate your bank offers will also reflect market expectations of future interest rates.

In other words, fixing today doesn't necessarily mean you're getting ahead of tomorrow's rate increase.

You're buying certainty at a price.


What Would a 0.25% Interest Rate Increase Actually Cost Your Farm?

Let's assume your farm has $2 million in debt.

A 0.25% interest rate increase represents an additional $5,000 in annual interest expense, assuming the full amount is outstanding for twelve months.

A 0.50% increase means another $10,000.

A full 1.00% increase would cost $20,000.

Those are real dollars, but the next question is more important.

What difference would that make to your business?

If your budget anticipates generating a $300,000 operating cash surplus, would another $5,000 or $10,000 in interest materially change your plans?

Perhaps not.

But if your forecast cash position is already tight, an additional $10,000 could be significant.

The answer depends on your farm's financial position, not the latest interest rate headline.

And we should be looking beyond this season. What happens to cash flow next year if grain prices weaken, yields disappoint or operating costs remain elevated?

Understanding those possibilities is far more useful than trying to second-guess the RBA.


Fixed Interest Rates: Certainty Comes at a Cost

Let's say your current variable interest rate is 6.50% and your bank offers a two-year fixed rate of 7.00%.

On $2 million of debt, that's an additional $10,000 a year compared with today's variable rate.

You're effectively agreeing to pay an extra $20,000 over two years compared with remaining at today's variable rate, assuming that rate remains unchanged and the full debt stays outstanding.

Of course, variable rates won't necessarily remain unchanged. They could rise or fall.

That's the point.

A fixed rate is not automatically a cheaper rate. It's the price you agree to pay for certainty.

That certainty may be valuable, particularly if it protects a cash flow outcome important to the family.

But certainty also comes with another cost that is sometimes overlooked.

Flexibility.

Farming businesses rarely operate exactly as planned. Seasonal income varies, debt balances change and opportunities arise.

Depending on the loan agreement, fixing may restrict your ability to repay debt early, restructure borrowing or take advantage of lower interest rates without additional costs.

Before fixing, understand what you're giving up.


When Does Fixing Farm Loan Interest Rates Make Sense?

I don't have an objection to fixed interest rates. Quite the opposite.

Throughout my treasury career, managing interest rate exposures was an important part of protecting business cash flow and financial performance.

But hedging, which is simply protecting against an unwanted movement in interest rates, should be part of a deliberate financial risk management strategy.

Not a reaction to a newspaper headline.

For some farming businesses, fixing a portion of debt for one to three years may provide valuable cash flow confidence.

For others, maintaining variable rates and the flexibility they provide may be more appropriate.

And often, a combination of fixed and variable borrowing makes sense.

The objective should be to strike a sensible balance between cost, flexibility and protecting the financial outcomes you want to achieve.

That might mean protecting sufficient cash flow to meet debt repayments, fund planned capital expenditure or preserve the family's financial position through a difficult season.

The starting point should always be what you're trying to protect, not what you think interest rates will do.


Sometimes Doing Nothing Is the Right Financial Decision

In my June 2024 article on managing interest rate risk, I made the point that remains just as relevant today.

Sometimes doing nothing is a perfectly valid strategy.

But there's a difference between doing nothing because you haven't thought about the issue and deliberately deciding to remain on variable rates because you've examined the alternatives.

The first is leaving your business exposed without understanding the consequences.

The second is an informed management decision.

Before fixing interest rates, understand the dollars involved, the potential impact on your cash flow, the cost of fixing and the flexibility you might lose.

Then make the decision that best supports your farm business objectives.

 

Because managing interest rate risk isn't about being right on interest rates. It's about making sure your farm business can achieve its goals, even when interest rates don't behave as expected.

 
 
Robert-Barnes.webp

Hi, I'm Robert

I bring business thinking to family farms focused on long-term resilience. Combining financial analysis and business intelligence with your farming skills to reduce stress and create more certainty.

Subscribe to get updates delivered to your inbox.

bottom of page